Image
Icon

Directory

IconAssociations and Institutes
IconBBBEE Consulting and Verification Agencies
IconCompare Medical Scheme Benefits
IconConsumer Protection
IconCorporate Governance
IconCredit Bureaus
IconEmergency Medical Rescue
IconExpatriate Cover
IconHealthcare Consultants
IconMedical Aid Brokers
IconMedical Aid Schemes
IconMedical Malpractice Cover
IconMedical Schemes Trustees Liability Insurance
IconMedical Service Providers
IconOmbud
IconOnline Quotes
IconPublications
IconRegulatory Authorities
IconWellness Programs
Image
  Subscribe To »

Can an exemption clause or disclaimer protect you from a liability?

Published

2018

Thu

12

Jul

 

By Pariksha Moodley
Camargue Underwriting Managers (Pty) Ltd

Disclaimers are everywhere - anytime someone is warning you of something or letting you know something for your own good, it’s a disclaimer.

Remember when one woman sued McDonald’s for spilling hot coffee on herself and won $2 million? After that the Company upped the disclaimer on their cup - this coffee is SUPER HOT - be careful.  

The above example left me pondering - are my colleagues familiar with the law in relation to disclaimers and what have I done to make our clients and brokers aware of it? The outcome has been this short article.

As a starting point a clause that excludes the liability on the part of a person or company, whether it be a hospital, hotel, restaurant, shopping mall, a tourist attraction or even a petrol-service station can be incorporated into an agreement between two parties, either as an agreed term in a contract, or in a notice displayed on the premises. When it is contained in the written agreement, it is referred to as an exemption or exclusion clause, and when it is displayed, it is referred to as a disclaimer notice.

On either basis, the party inserting the clause or displaying the notice may avoid liability for his or her actions. Whether such a clause will be upheld will depend always on the circumstances of each particular case.

It is worth mentioning that contracts, terms or notices excluding the liability of a party, as a general rule, are valid. Previously, a consumer could be held to a disclaimer notice where the consumer was aware of the notice or if the supplier took reasonable steps to bring the notice to the attention of the customer.

The Consumer Protection Act of 2008 (“the CPA”) has brought in stringent requirements which control the use of exemption provisions in consumer agreements. The introduction of the CPA has led to any such signs or provisions being interpreted strictly and most likely in favour of the consumer.

The CPA has placed a significant burden on the supplier to ensure that the nature and effect of the provision/notice is drawn to the attention of the consumer in conspicuous manner and form that is likely to draw the attention of an ordinarily alert consumer, considering the specific circumstances. This must be done before a consumer enters into a transaction, starts to engage in an activity, enters or gains access to the facility. There is an even greater burden where such a risk is an unusual risk or one that cannot be reasonably foreseen.

Where a disclaimer is erected, the type of premises, specific layout and other physical characteristics will play a role in determining whether the disclaimer was displayed in a conspicuous manner. Generally, such notices must be visible, large enough to be seen and read. These notices must appear at various locations in sufficient numbers on the premises of the establishment where the risk might occur.

Even after the supplier has gone through the effort to ensure that the disclaimer has been drawn to the attention of the consumer the exemption provision still subjected to a fairness test.

Whether the exemption term or notice is seemingly reasonable and fair will depend on each circumstance. However, when one is dealing with the exclusion of liability for death or personal injury, the exemption provision is presumed unfair and the supplier has the burden to prove that the exemption provision or notice is fair.

Exemption clauses and disclaimers are all beneficial to insurers (especially in relation to public liability policies) as they often have the effect of limiting the insurers' exposure and should not be overlooked when one is dealing with any particular claim. However, the insurer or supplier should never rely solely on a disclaimer as the defence to any claim. The insurer should always ascertain if the disclaimer meets the requirements of the CPA and investigate the circumstances of each claim before placing reliance on the exemption clause or disclaimer. 

 
Source: Camargue Underwriting Managers
 
« Back to previous page Print this page » |
 

Breaking News »

Introducing Our New Website!

The Insurance Gateway® team is excited to share our new website with you. Given our strategic objectives for 2019 and the fact that our last website redesign was over five years ago, we decided on a much anticipated ...
Read More »

  

Understanding non-disclosure

It is sometimes, incorrectly, thought that mere non-disclosure by an insured of any fact/s entitles the insurer to avoid the insurance policy. The non-disclosure, or if it is a positive false disclosure, the misrepresentation, ...
Read More »

  

Risk management for the healthcare industry: the importance of checklists

Surgery is becoming ever more sophisticated and complex, and the rise of the super-specialist surgeon complements a modern world in which what we know about the human body is constantly evolving and improving, ...
Read More »

  

Managing the medical malpractice litigation crush

Readers will have read of the enormous pressure placed on both the public and private healthcare sectors by an ever-increasing number of medical malpractice claims and quantum of awards or settlements of those ...
Read More »

 

More News »

Image

Investment »

Image

Life »

Image

Retirement »

Image

Short-term »

Image
Image
Advertise Here

From The Glossary »

Icon

Underweight:

An investment portfolio is termed "underweight" when it holds a below index weighting in a particular share or equity sector.
More Definitions »

 

Advertise

 

eZine

 

Contact IG

 

Media Pack

 

RSS Feeds

By using this website you agree to the Terms of Use.
Copyright © Insurance Gateway (Pty) Ltd 2004 - 2019. All Rights Reserved.